Saturday, March 26, 2011

Bastardizing "Problem Solving"


Drug courts, heavily promoted as a novel way to holistically resolve issues concerning addiction, have generated a fair amount of data on their clients (findings on recidivism rates are still sorely lacking despite the acknowledged need to examine this angle). They have also generated a substantial amount of critique from defense attorneys. But yesterday's This American Life broadcast shed light on something quite different: A drug court in Georgia that seems to operate under very different basic premises than the general problem-solving paradigm. Here's the abstract of Part One:

Ira reports from Glynn County Georgia on Superior Court Judge Amanda Williams and how she runs the drug courts in Glynn, Camden and Wayne counties. We hear the story of Lindsey Dills, who forges two checks on her parents' checking account when she's 17, one for $40 and one for $60, and ends up in drug court for five and a half years, including 14 months behind bars, and then she serves another five years after that—six months of it in Arrendale State Prison, the other four and a half on probation. The average drug court program in the U.S. lasts 15 months. But one main way that Judge Williams' drug court is different from most is how punitive it is. Such long jail sentences are contrary to the philosophy of drug court, as well as the guidelines of the National Association of Drug Court Professionals. For violating drug court rules, Lindsey not only does jail terms of 51 days, 90 days and 104 days, Judge Williams sends her on what she calls an "indefinite sentence," where she did not specify when Lindsey would get out.

The full broadcast will be available here on Sunday.

-----------
Props to Susan Dennehy for the link.

5 comments:

Prisoner Re-entry Consulting said...

Which drug court model has this court elected to follow? Where are the comprehensive service delivery that have been shown to positively impact the rate of recidivism. One tenet of the drug court model is flash incarceration (short periods of incarceration) has this judge ever heard of this?

With that being said I must say that I agree research has yet to support the notion that drug and/or parolee re-entry courts provide the biggest bang for your buck in reducing the rate of recidivism.

Hadar Aviram said...

Apparently the Georgia judge is operating on her own accord, not under any sort of established model. Some of the more bizarre and outrageous occurrences (telling people they are to be locked up for 28 days, but forgetting about them for weeks and ordering that they should not have contact with family members) seem to have taken place behind closed doors.

It is truly a shocking story. I really recommend it.

Jennifer said...

Judge Williams could have also been featured on "TAL"'s program about petty tyrants. She's using drug court to feed her own power hunger. It is an appalling example of how a single judge can do tremendous, irreversible harm.

Anonymous said...

http://www.ImpeachJudgeWilliams.com/

ssb-9a said...

Please report on this! All of Georgia and the rest of the country needs to know! http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/430/very-tough-love Please help us! We have been suffering since this woman took office in 1990! Now that her power-mad corruption has finally reached national attention we have a chance to finally get rid of her. Don't believe there's real corruption in Brunswick? Our local paper has still yet to print one word about this. Listen to the podcast. Google her name. This doesn't even address her conduct in civil and criminal court! Thank you. http://impeachjudgewilliams.com/what-you-can-do/

Read more at Jacksonville.com: http://jacksonville.com/news/georgia/2011-03-26/story/glynn-county-drug-court-focus-american-life-episode-airing-today#comment-386706#ixzz1I1c0qsWc